George
Lucas thought he was in a recent case concerning the stormtrooper helmets,
featured in the original Star Wars film.
Back in
1976 when Star Wars episode IV was being produced, Andrew Ainsworth, a young
industrial design graduate here in England, was approached to design a helmet based
on a set of drawings. He spent two days
producing the prototype for the helmets used in the film. No written agreement for the production of
these helmets existed.
Mr Ainsworth
retained the moulds which gathered dust for years until 2002 when he sold a
helmet and some other items for £60,000 at auction. Recognising the nostalgic value of these
authentic articles, he began selling further helmets based on the original moulds
through his website including a number in the US.
In 2004
George Lucas and others issued proceedings against Mr Ainsworth in the US for
$20,000,000 on the basis that Mr Ainsworth did not own the Intellectual Property
(“IP”) rights in the helmets and therefore had no right to sell them. George Lucas was successful in his claim in the
US courts but as Mr Ainsworth had no assets there, the court battle moved to
the UK.
After
spending around £700,000 defending the claim, Mr Ainsworth was, on the whole,
successful in his defence.
The main
issue for the UK courts to consider, which was ultimately decided in the
Supreme Court, was whether the helmets qualified as works of sculpture in which
case they would be protected by copyright (which lasts for the life of the
author plus 70 years) or whether they were simply functional costumes (in which
case the protection would be limited to 15 years from the date they were
marketed).
The Supreme
Court ruled that the helmets lacked the necessary quality of artistic creation
required of a sculpture. The protection
had therefore expired and Mr Ainsworth was free to use and sell the helmets.
This case
highlights the importance of ensuring that any IP you create or use is dealt
with properly and the potentially huge costs involved when it is not. There are many simple and cost effective ways
of protecting your ideas and your business.
